THE STATE OF LAW AND DEMOCRACY: THE REALITY OF STATE IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL SYSTEM IN INDONESIA

Husni Thamrin; Muhammad Arganata Thamrin; Muhammad Husni Fahrudin

doi:10.56301/awl.v8i2.2028

Husni Thamrin Awang Long School of Law, Samarinda, Indonesia
Muhammad Arganata Thamrin Awang Long School of Law, Samarinda, Indonesia
Muhammad Husni Fahrudin Awang Long School of Law, Samarinda, Indonesia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.56301/awl.v8i2.2028

Keywords: Rule of Law, Constitutional Democracy, 2024 Election, Responsive Law, Constitutionalism

Abstract

Indonesia constitutionally affirms itself as a state based on law (rechtsstaat), but in practice, tensions often arise between the supremacy of law and political interests. This article aims to analyze the dialectical relationship between the concept of the rule of law and democracy in the Indonesian constitutional system, particularly in the context of post-2024 election dynamics. Using a normative legal approach and an analysis of responsive legal typology by Philippe Nonet and Philip Selznick, this study finds that law enforcement in Indonesia still faces major challenges in the form of legal politicization, the weakening of independent institutions, and a shift towards semantic constitutionalism. This study concludes that strengthening constitutional democracy requires the integration of responsive law, strong political ethics, and constitutional adaptation to digital disruption to maintain genuine popular sovereignty.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Adhani, H. (2024). The Indonesian Constitutional Court in the digital era: Efforts to uphold the constitution, substantive justice, and a culture of constitutional awareness. Journal of Law Enforcement and Justice, 5(1), 15–29.
Antasari, RR (2019). A study of the development of types of legal order in Indonesia from the perspective of Nonet-Selznick's thinking towards just law. Nurani: Journal of Sharia and Community Studies, 19(1), 103–118.
Arliman, L. (2020). The Position of Independent State Institutions in Indonesia to Achieve the Goals of a Legal State. Kertha Semaya: Journal of Legal Studies, 8(7), 1030–1043.
Baidowi, A. (2023). The rule of law and democracy in Indonesia: Historical and contemporary perspectives. Resolution: Journal of Social Politics, 3(1), 45–60.
Budiardjo, M. (2013). Basics of political science. Gramedia Pustaka Utama.
Djauzie, MZ (2025). Pancasila as a grundnorm according to Hans Kelsen's pure legal theory and the responsive legal theory by Philippe Nonet and Philip Selznick. To-Ra Law Journal, 11(1), 239–252.
Ginting, FPP, & Saragih, A. (2018). The illusion of substantive democracy in Indonesia: A critique of the implementation of the parliamentary threshold. Politeia: Journal of Political Science, 10(2), 79–90.
Hadjono, PM (1987). Legal protection for the Indonesian people. Bina Ilmu.
Khoirunnisa, PD, & Triadi, I. (2024). Transformation of constitutional law in the digital era: Challenges and opportunities. SYARIAH: Journal of Legal Studies, 1(3), 105–112.
Liddle, RW, et al. (2012). Improving the quality of democracy in Indonesia. Paramadina Endowment Foundation.
Musyarofah, L., & Septiani, E. (2024). The influence of Philip Nonet and Selznick's thinking on the development of autonomous law in developing regions. Student Research Scientific Journal, 2(6), 344–352.
Nurmansyah, N. (2024). Post-truth politics: Challenges for mainstream media in Indonesia in facing the wave of hoaxes. Tambusai Education Journal, 8(3), 47475–47480.
Pralampita, T. (2024). The rule of law and democracy in relation to their implementation in Indonesia. ISO Journal: Journal of Social, Political and Humanitarian Sciences, 4(2), 18–30.
Rundengan, S. (2022). Problems of the 2024 Simultaneous Elections and Regulatory Reconstruction. KPU Law Book.
Samekto, FA (2013). The relationship between law and power: Seeing law from a realistic perspective. Unsyiah Law Journal.
Soekanto, S., & Mamudji, S. (2006). Normative legal research: a brief review. Rajawali Pres.
Surbakti, R. (2008). Engineering the election system to build a democratic political order. Kemitraan.
Syifaurrohmah, SZ (2025). Legal theory from the Robert Nonet and Philip Selznick era and its relevance to sustainable development in Indonesia. Decentralization: Journal of Law, Public Policy, and Governance, 2(4), 168–177.
Thamrin, H. (2024). The rule of law and democracy: The reality of statehood in the Indonesian constitutional system [Professor's Inaugural Speech]. Awang Long College of Law.
Ulfah, N., Hidayah, Y., & Trihastuti, M. (2020). The urgency of democratic ethics in the global era: Building ethics in expressing opinions. Journal of Citizenship Education.
Wahyuni. (2024). Legal and democratic reform after the 2024 General Election. Madika: Journal of Politics and Governance, 4(2), 146–157.
Widodo, MT (2025). Challenges of constitutional implementation in the digital era: A legal and human rights perspective. Renvoi Journal: Journal of Law and Sharia, 3(2).
Winata, MR, & Agustine, OV (2024). Reconnecting law and technological disruption through constitutional interpretation to support sustainable economic development. Indonesian Journal of Legislation, 21(1), 55–68.